Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


15 February 2023

Long-haul flights can be justified in climate fight

From Shawn Charland, Ottawa, Canada

I was interested to read about Graham Lawton's life-affirming trip to see research work in Uganda. He mentions the climate crisis and his guilt about the long-haul flight required to get there. The balance of the piece cogently explains the steep scientific cost if research communities were to adopt a moratorium on long-haul flights( 3 …

15 February 2023

On the idea that there is a mirror universe (1)

From Ray Cannon, Camberley, Surrey, UK

Since antimatter is identical to matter flowing in the opposite direction through time, my assumption is that the mirror universe is filled with antimatter. So, a key question posed for our universe – "where has all the antimatter gone?" – is answered( 28 January, p 38 ).

15 February 2023

On the idea that there is a mirror universe (2)

From Adam Huntley, St Albans, Hertfordshire, UK

Knowing the scientific world's love for new names to describe its shiny new concepts, it is surely just a matter of time before the mirror universe gets this treatment. Perhaps it will become known as the "mirroverse" or maybe the more accurate "biverse"?

15 February 2023

On the idea that there is a mirror universe (3)

From Mike Phair, Redmond, Washington, US

Will our universe and the mirror universe ever stop expanding away from each other and instead start accelerating back together, perhaps due to some underlying force of attraction between the two? Might a collision of these universes lead to a so-called big crunch scenario, spawning another big bang?

15 February 2023

Could melting robot be a sign of things to come?

From HildaRuth Beaumont, Brighton, UK

In the movie Terminator 2: Judgment Day , the villain of the piece is the T-1000, a killer robot composed of a shape-shifting metal alloy. There is clear resonance here with the robot created by Carmel Majidi and his colleagues( 4 February, p 12 ). Is this a case of science fiction in the process …

15 February 2023

All the things the aether theory did for science

From Dave Tarpley, Concord, California, US

Reader Nick Canning says the aether theory was "ascientific"( 28 January, p 54 ). However, this theory was one of the most fruitful in the history of science. It was useful during the development of electrodynamics, allowing James Clerk Maxwell to perceive light as electromagnetic. Mathematical and mechanical models of the aether enabled physicists to …

15 February 2023

Too premature to think of banning gas stoves

From Liz Tucker, London, UK

I understand the health and ecological problems with gas stoves that are concerning authorities in the US, but it seems unrealistic to ban them in favour of electric stoves. In the 1970s, my flatmates and I would huddle round the gas oven to keep warm during power cuts. Amid warnings of power cuts in the …

15 February 2023

A wise Bigfoot may choose to steer clear of bears

From Bryn Glover, Kirkby Malzeard, North Yorkshire, UK

It occurred to me on reading your report about Bigfoot sightings correlating with higher numbers of black bears in the US that if I belonged to a small, endangered family group of surviving Sasquatch, the last place I would choose to live would be somewhere that is rife with competing bears( 4 February, p 11 …

15 February 2023

Mars study provides a welcome alternative

From Natalie Roberts, Watford, Hertfordshire, UK

You report that a small base of six people at the Martian poles could support themselves energy-wise with a combination of solar power and well-placed wind turbines( 7 January, p 13 ). This should come as a relief to anyone who has read How To by Randall Munroe. In the chapter "How to Power Your …

15 February 2023

Database of essays could head off ChatGPT cheats

From Colin Sutton, Sydney, Australia

If the OpenAI company recorded all the responses its ChatGPT AI sent to students who get it to write their homework, it could easily provide a service for schools to check their essays. This might allay fears that it will be used to cheat( 21 January, p 15 ).

15 February 2023

Remember, AI is fixing bugs in our fallible code

From Paul Bethel, London, UK

In your look at how the AI ChatGPT is being used to find and fix bugs in computer code, I had to chuckle at the quote: "We don't want to rely totally on the AI as it is not infallible." Unlike humans( 4 February, p 16 )?

15 February 2023

Come to Houston and buy a bag full of human waste

From Dave Dyer, Houston, Texas, US

Your story on the potential for using human waste as fertiliser is a bit late. Houston has been bagging up our dried sewage and selling it as fertiliser under the name Hou-Actinite for decades. It is recycled, natural and all organic! If you ever come to Texas, I can show you where to buy a …

Issue no. 3426 published 18 February 2023