Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


22 February 2023

The 2000-watt challenge sparks a lot of interest (1)

From Roy Harrison, Verwood, Dorset, UK

James Dinneen's article on the challenge of reducing our rate of energy consumption to 2000 watts encouraged me to put some numbers into a calculator( 11 February, p 36 ). Our car used 748 litres of fuel over a period of 381 days. Taking the energy value and density of diesel as 43.1 megajoules per …

22 February 2023

The 2000-watt challenge sparks a lot of interest (2)

From Robert Peck, York, UK

The difference between averaged power usage, as imagined in the 2000-watt challenge, and peak power usage is important. It is the latter value that grids must be designed to supply, with power stations ready to fire up to meet it, especially when renewable inputs are lacking. These stations are usually gas fired, and this makes …

22 February 2023

The 2000-watt challenge sparks a lot of interest (3)

From Richard Oliver, Nottingham, UK

Dinneen switched from drying his clothes in a powered dryer to hanging them indoors. Does this really use less energy? Surely, the energy to evaporate the water is the same regardless. Of course, the best thing would be to hang clothes outside, but, where this isn't an option, the evaporation would cool a building and …

22 February 2023

Dark matter is just the pull of other universes

From Jeffrey McClure, Salado, Texas, US

There is a relatively simple solution to the question of dark matter – the unseen mass thought to be exerting an additional gravitational effect on galaxies( 11 February, p 46 ). In his book The Elegant Universe: Superstrings, hidden dimensions, and the quest for the ultimate theory , Brian Greene explains that string theory postulates …

22 February 2023

Eel migration may have got longer very slowly

From Nuala Lonie, Linlithgow, West Lothian, UK

Reader Chris Hall wonders what Darwinian forces might drive European eels to undertake a 12,000-kilometre journey across the Atlantic and back to breed. This could be an adaptation to the formation of the ocean about 150 million years ago via slow spreading of tectonic plates( Letters, 11 February ). Perhaps eel ancestors had breeding grounds …

22 February 2023

Many cultures don't regard nature this way

From James Fradgley, Wimborne, Dorset, UK

You say that "for much of recent human history, nature has been regarded as mere property... to be exploited". Many cultures don't see nature that way at all, and I suggest it is the Judaeo-Christian idea that we have "dominion over nature" that is the main problem( 11 February, p 26 ).

22 February 2023

Is this how our immune systems keep fighting fit?

From Jim McHardy, Clydebank, West Dunbartonshire, UK

Your feature on immunity states that the immune system wastes its resources attacking the cytomegalovirus pathogen, which persists nonetheless. If this virus rings our immune alarm bell so much, you might assume that the immune system would have evolved to kill it off( 4 February, p 43 ). Could this be like countries holding war …

22 February 2023

I fear the spread of bird flu to many more species

From John Davnall, Manchester, UK

You report that mammals such as foxes have been infected by the current bird flu virus. This has been attributed to scavenging of the carcasses of infected birds( 11 February, p 8 ). It seems to me only a matter of time before other wild mammals – especially rats, as scavengers, and squirrels, as raiders …

22 February 2023

Pondering the limits of mammalian mutualism

From Virginia Lowe, Melbourne, Australia

You report that mongooses and warthogs display "the only known mammal-mammal mutualism in the world". That does seem to be true of land-based mammals( 4 February, p 44 ). I wonder if there are valid examples for marine mammals, such as seals leaving their young pups to be watched over in sea lion nurseries, or …

22 February 2023

For the record

Andrew Rogoyski works at the University of Surrey, UK ( 4 February, p 25 )

Issue no. 3427 published 25 February 2023