Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


1 March 2023

True value of clean rivers is far bigger than we think

From Paul Whiteley, Bittaford, Devon, UK

You say that £870 million a year is the supposed beneficial impact on the UK's health thanks to rivers and lakes encouraging physical activity and relaxation. I wonder if there is another, hidden cost that should be added in due to polluted waters( Leader, 18 February ). Back in 1995, I swam in a river …

1 March 2023

Lunar dust sunshield may do more harm than good

From Bryn Glover, Kirkby Malzeard, North Yorkshire, UK

Your story on using moon dust to create a sunshield for Earth implies that the 1 million tonnes of dust needed would have to be replaced at the rate of 200,000 tonnes a day. While you mention the possible use of a railgun to propel the dust into space, there would need to be infrastructure …

1 March 2023

Let's look for evidence of interstellar shift on Earth

From John McIntosh, Birkenhead, Merseyside, UK

"Into the void" suggests we may risk an increase in cosmic rays as our planet passes into a new area of interstellar space in about 2000 years. We entered the area we are currently in around 60,000 years ago. I suggest calculating when previous transitions occurred to see if they tally with events in Earth's …

1 March 2023

Old tech may be just what the climate crisis needs (1)

From Eric Kvaalen, Les Essarts-le-Roi, France

I was glad to see Mark Jacobson rectifying some of the overblown optimism around carbon capture and storage, direct air capture, "blue hydrogen" and so on( 18 February, p 27 ). He didn't mention electrification of vehicles, but there are significant problems with this as well, on a global scale. I think these downsides should …

1 March 2023

Old tech may be just what the climate crisis needs (2)

From Gethin Bermingham, Lancaster, UK

Jacobson makes the point that we will only achieve our climate goals on the short timescales necessary if we use existing technologies. I and most people would agree. Unfortunately, he then includes a yet-to-be developed technology as one of the solutions. Storage for renewables, despite what he says, is nowhere near ready to help support …

1 March 2023

Remember, kimchi isn't the only fermented food

From Avril Arthur-Goettig, Munich, Germany

We hear more and more about fermented foods and how good they are for our microbiome and hence our immune system. But it is frustrating to always hear kimchi given as the example( 4 February, p 41 ). What about our centuries-old European tradition of fermenting cabbage or root vegetables to provide nutrients and, above …

1 March 2023

Let's turn the wood wide web on its head

From Paul Rendell, Tywyn, Gwynedd, UK

You report doubts about the "wood wide web", in which trees communicate and share resources via buried fungi. I think it is more likely that the fungi are in charge, actively encouraging certain types of tree to grow in certain spots. The fungi could favour mixed woodland species and discourage monocultures( 18 February, p 10 …

1 March 2023

On the hope that climate extremes are unlikely

From Robert Antonucci, Santa Barbara, California, US

Is a 4°C temperature rise by 2100 ruled out? Graham Lawton assures us that the current models say so. However, I wonder if there is an assumption that climate feedbacks will be constrained. The models don't include release of methane from permafrost at the observed and rapidly rising level. In the past few years, anthropogenic …

1 March 2023

Worriers, resolve to go fretless for Lent!

From Peter Slessenger, Reading, Berkshire, UK

Kayt Sukel reports on people scheduling set periods when they are allowed to worry as a way of managing and reducing paranoia. I suggested another approach to someone, that they give up worrying for Lent, as they were always fretting about something. They felt so much better that they did this every year( 11 February, …

1 March 2023

All hail energy saving, now let's look at water

From Maria Felice, Bristol, UK

I thoroughly enjoyed reading your feature on the 2000-watt energy-saving challenge( 11 February, p 36 ). We now need something similar for water consumption. There are few tools to track usage and not that much talk about it. Shouldn't we give water use the attention it deserves, or, like energy, are we going to leave …

1 March 2023

Floating eyes in the sky are really nothing new at all

From Steve Johns, Axedale, Victoria, Australia

I find it amazing that it has taken China and the US until now to think of spying on each other using flying objects. I suggest the outrage may be manufactured for immediate political ends( 11 February, p 9 ).

Issue no. 3428 published 4 March 2023